Chaya & Cacao on Isla Mujeres, Mexico Redefines and Refines Island Fare - Madison Eats
  • Black Lives Matter
  • Private and Group Events
  • Gift Certificates
  • Blog
  • COVID-19 Update: Read About The Enhanced Safety Measures We're Taking For Our Guests

    Chaya & Cacao on Isla Mujeres, Mexico Redefines and Refines Island Fare

    Apr 05 2018

    Chaya & CacaoNestled under a palm frond canopy, just a short walk from Isla Mujeres’ North Beach is Chef Lori Dumm’s newest restaurant on Isla Mujeres, Mexico–Chaya & Cacao. Chaya & Cacao redefines and refines island fare. Chef Dumm began her island restaurateur life with the opening of Mango Cafe, now one of the island’s most popular dining destinations (under different ownership, but still featuring much of her menu), followed by Lola’s and Lolita’s where she contributed creatively to the menu development. She has always focused on fresh, innovative fare reflecting a fusion of Latin American and Caribbean flavors, taking favorites such as eggs benedict and adding spices and toppings that evoke the tropical sun and heat. Her current iteration of island fresh, farm-to-table cuisine is unparalleled. Chaya & Cacao’s menu reflects a culinary finesse that Chef Dumm delivers in partnership with the talented Head Chef Arturo Lopez (formerly of Mayan Beach Club). Chef Dumm has refined her style, offering tantalizing, healthy fare that is at the same time satisfying and refreshing, reflecting the seasonal and sustainable offerings of the island.

    Here are my top five favorite dishes at Chaya & Cacao.


    Dirty Chai

    Dirty Coconut Chai Latte

    Dirty Coconut Chai Latte

    Coconut milk, chai tea with espresso ice cubes and a sprinkle of cinnamon. Not too sweet, perfect for non-coffee drinkers, or just an afternoon pick me up. 

    Maca Smoothie

    What can be better than an almond butter, cacao nib and banana smoothie? One that adds the superfood benefits of maca and still tastes delicious!! 


    Banana Bread

    I am not vegan. Let’s be clear. And I generally steer clear of vegan desserts. But the baked goods made from scratch are amazing!!! Try the banana bread – perfectly moist, with a delightful crunch of nuts leavened with flax seed. It’s amazing.


    Avocado Toast two ways

    Don’t just try one, try both! One option features fresh spring vegetables such as asparagus, topped with a sunny side up egg and pesto, while the other version highlights the Island’s tropical vibe, the diced mango playing eloquently with pickled onion atop the egg. Both are serves on gluten-free toast smeared with roasted beet hummus (see below for recipe). 


    Lionfish specials

    Lori Dumm, Owner Chaya & Cacao

    Lori Dumm, Owner Chaya & Cacao

    When you eat lionfish, not only are you doing good for your body, but also for the environment. It is one of the only sustainably caught fish on the island, and is an invasive species. It is not available every day, but when it is, you might find lionfish tostadas with chipotle aioli & mango pico de gallo or it’s served with  yucca, passion fruit, crispy leeks & purslane on the menu tonight. Caribbean flavors at their best!


    Roasted Beet hummus

    This is a totally amazing addition to your breakfast or lunch! 


    1 small roasted beet
    1 3/4 cup cooked chickpeas, mostly drained
    zest of 1 large lemon
    juice of 1/2 a lemon
    pinch salt and black pepper
    2 cloves garlic, minced
    2 Tbsp tahini
    1/4 cup extra virgin olive oil

    1 tsp chipotle in adobo – optional


    Cool and peel the beet, then dice it and place it in your food processor.

    Blend until only small bits remain.
    Add remaining ingredients except for olive oil and blend until smooth.
    Add in olive oil as the hummus is mixing.
    Taste and adjust seasonings as needed, adding more salt, lemon juice, or olive oil if needed.

    Add a bit of water if needed.


    Otehlia Cassidy stands in front of the WI State Capitol.

    Subscribe To Our Newsletter

    Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from Madison Eats Food Tours!

    You have Successfully Subscribed!